1990
NUNSENSE
1992
SWEENEY TODD
THE ROCKY HORROR SHOW
SWING, SWING, SWING!
DANCING IN THE DARK
A NEW BRAIN
GUNMETAL BLUES
URINETOWN
2004
ZOOMA ZOOMA
2008
SWEENEY TODD
SUNDAY IN THE PARK WITH GEORGE
THE 25TH ANNUAL PUTNAM COUNTY SPELLING BEE
AVENUE Q
THE DROWSY CHAPERONE
IN THE HEIGHTS
1995
FALSETTOS
2001
PAGEANT
A…MY NAME WILL ALWAYS BE ALICE
AVENUE X
THE GIRL IN THE FRAME
JAMESTOWN GALS
MAN OF LA MANCHA
THE 25TH ANNUAL PUTNAM COUNTY SPELLING BEE
SWONDERFUL: THE NEW GERSHWIN MUSICAL
RING OF FIRE
FUN HOME
ALL IS CALM
DISASTER
Sean Greenan, LITTLE SHOP OF HORRORS
1995
John Fredo, FALSETTOS
Paul Maisano, COMPANY
Tony Sperry, A NEW BRAIN
John Fredo, URINETOWN
2008
John Fredo, SWEENEY TODD
Joe Wiens, BUDDY: THE BUDDY HOLLY STORY
Christian Brandjes, MY FAIR LADY
Eric Rawski, THE DROWSY CHAPERONE
Ricky Marchese, IN THE HEIGHTS
Marc Sacco, EVITA
Steve Copps, PETER & THE STARCATCHER
Mary Kate O’Connell, CLOSER THAN EVER
Lisa Ann Ludwig, INTO THE WOODS
Lisa Ann Ludwig, SONG OF SINGAPORE
Sheila McCarthy, WINGS
Loraine O’Donnell, PETE N KEELY
Kelli Bocock-Natale, SOPHIE TUCKER: LAST OF THE RED HOT MAMAS
Terrie George, FAMILIAR STRANGERS
2008
Lisa Ann Ludwig, SWEENEY TODD
Jenn Stafford, SUNDAY IN THE PARK WITH GEORGE
Michele Marie Roberts, EVITA
Renee Landrigan, ONCE
Dominique Kempf, RAGTIME
Curtis Lovell, COOKIN' AT THE COOKERY
Supporting Actor in a Musical
1992
Will Minsterman, SWEENEY TODD
Brian Harkins, A LITTLE NIGHT MUSIC
Tom Owen, PIPPIN
Brian Riggs, NO WAY TO TREAT A LADY
Tom Owen, EAT-TV
Louis Colaiacovo, JOLSON & COMPANY
Tom Owen, URINETOWN
Marc Sacco, ALTAR BOYZ
Louis Colaiacovo, FALSETTOS
Philip Farugia, MY FAIR LADY
Eric Rawski, OLIVER
Dudney Joseph, Jr., LA CAGE AUX FOLLES
Kevin Craig, HOW TO SUCCEED...
Joseph Donohue III, MILLION DOLLAR QUARTET
Kyle Bassett-Baran, RAGTIME
Supporting Actress in a Musical
Jeanmarie Lally, INTO THE WOODS
Janien Nola, BROADWAY 1960!
Syndi Starr, THE ROBBER BRIDEGROOM
1996
Rosalind Cramer, CABARET
Lona Geiser, COMPANY
Kathy Weese, 1940’S RADIO HOUR
Debbie Pappas, A NEW BRAIN
Amy Jakiel, RENT
Arin Lee Dandes, DISASTER
Lynne Kurdziel-Formato & Randall Kramer, HAIR
Randall Kramer, DANCING IN THE DARK
Randall Kramer, WINGS
Randall Kramer, 1940’S RADIO HOUR
2001
Doug Weyand, PAGEANT
Randall Kramer, A NEW BRAIN
Lisa Ann Ludwig, SOPHIE TUCKER: LAST OF THE RED HOT MAMAS
Randall Kramer, TICK, TICK…BOOM!
2008
Randall Kramer, SWEENEY TODD
Randall Kramer , SUNDAY IN THE PARK WITH GEORGE
Susan Drozd, MY FAIR LADY
Michael Walline, AIN'T MISBEHAVIN'
Susan Drozd, FUN HOME
Susan Drozd, ALL IS CALM
Lynne Kurdziel-Formato, HAIR
Kathy Weese & Doug Weyand, GODSPELL
Jeffry Denman, DANCING IN THE DARK
Anne Nicole Biancofiore, RODGERS & HART: A CELEBRATION
Michael J. Walline, PIPPIN
Kathy Weese, A NEW BRAIN
Michael J. Walline, SONG & DANCE
Lynne Kurdziel-Formato, THAT 70S REVUE
Michael J. Walline, FAMILIAR STRANGERS
Michael J. Walline, ALTAR BOYZ
Kristy E. Schupp, MY FAIR LADY
Michael Walline & Doug Weyand, 'SWONDERFUL: THE NEW GERSHWIN MUSICAL
Kristy E. Schupp, BUDDY: THE BUDDY HOLLY STORY
Michael Walline, IN THE HEIGHTS
John Fredo, SOPHISTICATED LADIES
Kristy E. Schupp, NICE WORK IF YOU CAN GET IT
Brian Cavanagh, THE ROCKY HORROR SHOW
Tom Kostusiak, WINGS
Chris Cavanagh, A NEW BRAIN
Chris Cavanagh, GUNMETAL BLUES
Chris Cavanagh , URINETOWN
Chris Cavanagh, FALSETTOS
Chris Schenk, GUNMETAL BLUES
Chris Schenk, RENEWING WRIGHT
Chris Schenk, URINETOWN
Chris Schenk, FAMILIAR STRANGERS
Chris Schenk, SUNDAY IN THE PARK WITH GEORGE
Kari Drozd, PETER & THE STARCATCHER