Awards History
MusicalFare Theatre recipients of Artie Awards, given for Excellence in Theatre in the WNY region.
Winners in select categories below, in chronological order.
NUNSENSE
1990
SWEENEY TODD
1992
THE ROCKY HORROR SHOW
SWING, SWING, SWING!
DANCING IN THE DARK
A NEW BRAIN
GUNMETAL BLUES
URINETOWN
ZOOMA ZOOMA
2004
SWEENEY TODD
2008
SUNDAY IN THE PARK WITH GEORGE
THE 25TH ANNUAL PUTNAM COUNTY SPELLING BEE
AVENUE Q
THE DROWSY CHAPERONE
IN THE HEIGHTS
WAITRESS
2025
FALSETTOS
1995
PAGEANT
2001
A…MY NAME WILL ALWAYS BE ALICE
AVENUE X
THE GIRL IN THE FRAME
JAMESTOWN GALS
MAN OF LA MANCHA
THE 25TH ANNUAL PUTNAM COUNTY SPELLING BEE
SWONDERFUL: THE NEW GERSHWIN MUSICAL
RING OF FIRE
FUN HOME
ALL IS CALM
DISASTER
STORIES OF LIFE
Sean Greenan
LITTLE SHOP OF HORRORS
John Fredo
FALSETTOS
1995
Paul Maisano
COMPANY
Tony Sperry
A NEW BRAIN
John Fredo
URINETOWN
John Fredo
SWEENEY TODD
2008
Joe Wiens
BUDDY: THE BUDDY HOLLY STORY
Christian Brandjes
MY FAIR LADY
Eric Rawski
THE DROWSY CHAPERONE
Ricky Marchese
IN THE HEIGHTS
Marc Sacco
EVITA
Steve Copps
PETER & THE STARCATCHER
Mary Kate O’Connell
CLOSER THAN EVER
Lisa Ann Ludwig
INTO THE WOODS
Lisa Ann Ludwig
SONG OF SINGAPORE
Sheila McCarthy
WINGS
Loraine O’Donnell
PETE N KEELY
Kelli Bocock-Natale
SOPHIE TUCKER: LAST OF THE RED HOT MAMAS
Terrie George
FAMILIAR STRANGERS
Lisa Ann Ludwig
SWEENEY TODD
2008
Jenn Stafford
SUNDAY IN THE PARK WITH GEORGE
Michele Marie Roberts
EVITA
Renee Landrigan
ONCE
Dominique Kempf
RAGTIME
Curtis Lovell
COOKIN' AT THE COOKERY
Maria Pedro
WAITRESS
2025
Will Minsterman
SWEENEY TODD
1992
Brian Harkins
A LITTLE NIGHT MUSIC
Tom Owen
PIPPIN
Brian Riggs
NO WAY TO TREAT A LADY
Tom Owen
EAT-TV
Louis Colaiacovo
JOLSON & COMPANY
Tom Owen
URINETOWN
Marc Sacco
ALTAR BOYZ
Louis Colaiacovo
FALSETTOS
Philip Farugia
MY FAIR LADY
Eric Rawski
OLIVER
Dudney Joseph, Jr.
LA CAGE AUX FOLLES
Kevin Craig
HOW TO SUCCEED...
Joseph Donohue III
MILLION DOLLAR QUARTET
Kyle Bassett-Baran
RAGTIME
Dave Spychalski
KINKY BOOTS
2025
Jeanmarie Lally
INTO THE WOODS
Janien Nola
BROADWAY 1960!
Syndi Starr
THE ROBBER BRIDEGROOM
Rosalind Cramer
CABARET
1996
Lona Geiser
COMPANY
Kathy Weese
1940’S RADIO HOUR
Debbie Pappas
A NEW BRAIN
Amy Jakiel
RENT
Arin Lee Dandes
DISASTER
Lynne Kurdziel-Formato & Randall Kramer
HAIR
Randall Kramer
DANCING IN THE DARK
Randall Kramer
WINGS
Randall Kramer
1940’S RADIO HOUR
Doug Weyand
PAGEANT
2001
Randall Kramer
A NEW BRAIN
Lisa Ann Ludwig
SOPHIE TUCKER: LAST OF THE RED HOT MAMAS
Randall Kramer
TICK, TICK…BOOM!
Randall Kramer
SWEENEY TODD
2008
Randall Kramer
SUNDAY IN THE PARK WITH GEORGE
Susan Drozd
MY FAIR LADY
Michael Walline
AIN'T MISBEHAVIN'
Susan Drozd
FUN HOME
Susan Drozd
ALL IS CALM
Susan Drozd
WAITRESS
2025
Lynne Kurdziel-Formato
HAIR
Kathy Weese & Doug Weyand
GODSPELL
Jeffry Denman
DANCING IN THE DARK
Michael J. Walline
SONG & DANCE
Anne Nicole Biancofiore
RODGERS & HART: A CELEBRATION
Michael J. Walline
PIPPIN
Kathy Weese
A NEW BRAIN
Lynne Kurdziel-Formato
THAT 70S REVUE
Michael J. Walline
FAMILIAR STRANGERS
Michael J. Walline
ALTAR BOYZ
Kristy E. Schupp
MY FAIR LADY
Michael Walline & Doug Weyand
'SWONDERFUL: THE NEW GERSHWIN MUSICAL
Kristy E. Schupp
BUDDY: THE BUDDY HOLLY STORY
Michael Walline
IN THE HEIGHTS
John Fredo
SOPHISTICATED LADIES
Kristy E. Schupp
NICE WORK IF YOU CAN GET IT
Michael Oliver-Walline
KINKY BOOTS
2025
Brian Cavanagh
THE ROCKY HORROR SHOW
Tom Kostusiak
WINGS
Chris Cavanagh
A NEW BRAIN
Chris Cavanagh
GUNMETAL BLUES
Chris Cavanagh
URINETOWN
Chris Cavanagh
FALSETTOS
Chris Schenk
GUNMETAL BLUES
Chris Schenk
RENEWING WRIGHT
Chris Schenk
URINETOWN
Chris Schenk
FAMILIAR STRANGERS
Chris Schenk
SUNDAY IN THE PARK WITH GEORGE
Kari Drozd
PETER & THE STARCATCHER